Answering Common Publishing Misconceptions from an Independent Publishing House

Answering Common Publishing Misconceptions from an Independent Publishing House

Introduction 

Thinking about publishing a book but confused by all the misconceptions out there? Let’s separate fact from myth—straight from an independent publishing house. 

At Austin Macauley Publishers, we specialize in partnership publishing, offering authors two types of contracts: 

  1. Partnership Contract: 

Both the author and the publisher financially contribute to the production and marketing of the book. 

  1. Standard Contract (also known as a ‘traditional’ contract): 

Includes the same services as the partnership model but with no author contribution. 

Austin Macauley Publishers helps authors explore their options and understand what a publisher does. Want to learn more about the publishing process and what we offer? Visit here. 

This blog will address and clarify common misconceptions about publishing to help readers make informed decisions. Our brilliant team has debunked the following myths to help aspiring authors understand the truth about publishing a book. 

Debunking Publishing Myths 

Misconceptions About Editing & Manuscript Quality 

Myth: The editor will fix all my grammar mistakes. 

Reality: While publishers provide proofreading, authors should submit a polished, readable manuscript first. 

It's true to a certain extent that the editor will fix errors, and that's exactly what Austin Macauley Publishers is here for. However, while your manuscript will go through a proofreading process with us, it's important for you as the author to make sure your book has the best possible chance of publication. The manuscript should have already undergone a proof edit and be in readable condition, so we can focus more on the story without being distracted by the mistakes. The good news is that plenty of websites and tools are available to help authors fix these issues before submission. 

Author Involvement & Creative Control 

Myth: Authors must have input over their books. 

Reality: Yes, authors should have creative input, but collaboration with the publisher is key. 

At Austin Macauley Publishers, we strongly believe that authors should have creative input in their work. As a publishing house, we also encourage authors to collaborate with us and remain open to feedback. With our experience in the industry, we understand what works, what’s standard, and what gives a book the best chance of success. Publishing is a collaborative effort, and the best results come from working together. We aim to balance the author's vision with professional guidance. 

Cost & Value of Partnership Publishing 

Myth: It costs more money to publish with a partnership publisher. 

Reality: Partnership publishing requires an upfront investment, but offers higher royalties, more creative control, and full professional production (editing, cover design, distribution). 

If you are offered a partnership agreement, it’s true that there is an upfront cost. However, this is balanced out with much more creative control for the author as well as much higher royalties. We still provide the same professional production support you would expect from a traditional publishing house. In many cases, this model can offer long-term benefits for the right author. 

Traditional vs. Alternative Publishing Paths 

Myth: Your book is only good if it's accepted by a traditional publisher. 

Reality: Many bestselling authors started with rejection or self-publishing. Success depends on quality, marketing, and interaction with the audience, not just the publishing model. 

At Austin Macauley Publishers, we don’t believe traditional publishing is the only path to success. For example, Beatrix Potter’s Peter Rabbit was rejected by seven publishers, and she chose to self-publish and went on to sell over 45 million copies. Today, authors have more options than ever, including self-publishing and hybrid publishing. It’s important to keep an open mind and explore the path that best suits your needs. 

Marketing & Author Responsibility 

Myth: I'm not responsible for promoting my book; my publisher is. 

Reality: Publishers can help, but authors must actively promote their work. 

While the publisher will do everything it can to support an author in promoting their book, readers are often more likely to connect with an author when that author is also engaged and visible. Authors who are active on social media, maintain a website, or participate in their local community are far more likely to build a strong and loyal fan base. 

Writing for Trends vs. Authenticity 

Myth: I must write a book in a trending genre. 

Reality: Chasing trends can feel inauthentic—readers crave originality. 

At Austin Macauley Publishers, we believe that chasing trends can often feel inauthentic. What truly resonates with readers is authenticity, as they can feel the passion in your writing. In fact, it's often the more unconventional books that end up standing out and succeeding. 

Conclusion 

The reality of publishing is often far different from the myths that surround it. At Austin Macauley Publishers, we have set out to debunk common misconceptions and help aspiring authors better understand the publishing world. 

We are open for submissions, so if you have a story to share, we would love to hear it. Submit your manuscript today and take the first step toward becoming a published author. Want to learn more about how to become an author? Read here.